|
Post by Zoom on Feb 5, 2013 23:41:20 GMT -6
I wanted to add my opinion because this is something I've noticed before, but after reading all the posts I have nothing left to say. Your opinions mesh perfectly with mine.
I will add something, though:
When I was a kid, Deltora Quest was my absolute favorite thing. I bought all the companion books. Though I outgrew it years and years ago, I still read it over now and then because it had such an impact on me growing up. And, you know, they're actually pretty good books. Everything lined up perfectly. PERFECTLY. There was not a single problem that went unresolved. I also loved the theme of "small things adding up to more than the sum of their parts".
But deus ex machina played a huge part. Almost nothing in that series should have gone the way it did. But I didn't care.
|
|
|
Post by sapphire on Feb 6, 2013 1:15:46 GMT -6
You know, now that I think about it, leaving loose ends in a story has always really bothered me. I don't read so that I can be left feeling uncomfortable and half-finished... I read for that satisfaction at the end of the book, you know? It's hard to achieve a book that feels complete but leaves loose ends. Maybe that's why so many of them are tied up in neat little packages. Not saying it can't be done - obviously it can, as our examples all prove - but it's really hard, as a writer, to earn that. Readers like to feel complete. I'm honestly afraid to go back and read my old favorites, from before I started college. I'm so much more picky about what I read now, I'm worried that I won't like them anymore.
|
|
|
Post by Endovia on Feb 6, 2013 21:29:46 GMT -6
Well, I'm the weird reader who likes some incompleteness. It feels more real to me when it's not perfect. I think I can appreciate it more as a work when it's more real. Sure, I like some completeness, ending (or not ending) a book in the beginning of the action because there's a sequel is plain annoying (I'm starting to avoid series because of this). Some stories are just cute when it's all happily ever after, but it's less satisfying for me now (than say when I was little) because I feel a certain fakeness. If you value your happy memories of those books, I recommend that you don't pick them up, Sapphire. There's a shelf of books that I looked at the other day, remembering how I loved them. I started reading one and wondered what/how I loved it because I thought it was awful. We change.
|
|
|
Post by sapphire on Feb 7, 2013 17:40:08 GMT -6
I don't like stories where everything ties together perfectly, or too easily. It has to make sense and read as if it would have happened in reality, and the occasional unresolved story doesn't bother me, as long as it's well-written, but stories with the main conflict left open at the end just get to me. Yeah, heh... I'm avoiding them deliberately. Not that I have time to reread things lately, anyway. There's always another new book.
|
|